Blog

Table of Contents

1. Core Instructor Traits to Prioritize
2. Communication Style and Instructional Approach
3. Evaluating Instructor Mindset and School Culture
4. Fit, Availability, and Learning Environment
5. Teaching Tools and Resources
6. Realistic Expectations and Student Responsibility
7. Peer Feedback and Reviews
8. Online & Hybrid Training Options
9. What the Experts Say
10. Final Thoughts: Choose Deliberately, Fly Confidently

Updated May 29, 2025

Industry data shows that a significant number of student pilots never complete their certificate—often due to instructional misalignment, unclear communication, or a lack of mentorship.

A great instructor doesn’t just teach flight maneuvers. They guide, motivate, and challenge you while creating an environment where learning is safe and rewarding.

This guide outlines the key traits to look for, how to evaluate instructor compatibility, and ways to make the most of your training.

1. Core Instructor Traits to Prioritize

Proven Experience and Transparent Credentials

The foundation of a solid instructor relationship starts with competence. An FAA-certificated CFI is the minimum requirement, but it’s equally important to look for signs of active instructional work, well-documented experience across flight categories, and relevant endorsements (CFII for instrument, MEI for multiengine, etc.).

Credentialed instructors often hold designations like the FAA Gold Seal CFI or advanced instructor ratings. These credentials typically reflect a consistent record of student checkride success, dedication to continued education, and structured teaching approaches.

Truly dedicated instructors often go a step further—they’re members of professional organizations like SAFE (Society of Aviation and Flight Educators) or NAFI (National Association of Flight Instructors). Membership in these associations shows a commitment to professional development, ongoing learning, and upholding high standards in aviation education.

However, even a newer instructor can be a great match if they follow a clear syllabus, and demonstrate strong preparation. Don't judge by flight hours alone—look at how they teach.

2. Communication Style and Instructional Approach

Outstanding flight instructors understand how to adjust their delivery to match the student. They don’t just lecture; they observe, listen, and translate complex concepts into clear, practical steps.

You’ll want an instructor who

• Can explain things without jargon.
• Regularly checks for understanding.
• Tailors their pacing based on your confidence and performance.
• Welcomes your questions without making you feel embarrassed.

Watch for instructors who provide honest feedback without being discouraging. Instruction should push you while remaining constructive. The best flight instructors blend the roles of coach, teacher, and mentor.

*Try this: After your first flight, ask yourself: “Did I leave that lesson clearer, more confident, and more curious?” If not, try flying with another instructor to compare styles.

3. Evaluating Instructor Mindset and School Culture

Beyond technical skills, look for instructors who demonstrate professionalism, humility, and dedication to teaching. Here are signs of that mindset:

• They show up prepared. Organized instructors have clear lesson plans, use tools like briefing materials or simulators, and document your progress with purpose.
• They focus on your growth, not just the hours. Rather than racing to log time, great instructors emphasize skill development and situational awareness.
• They’re continuously improving. Many top instructors stay involved in aviation organizations, subscribe to new training resources, and collaborate with peers to learn from each other.
• They accept feedback. A confident but humble instructor won’t be defensive if you raise concerns. They’ll listen, adapt, and strive to improve their instruction.

At the same time, observe the culture of the school or flying club:

• Are instructors and students interacting with respect and energy?
• Does the school seem focused on student outcomes or just transactions?
• How do they support students whose instructors leave or are unavailable?

Training with a community that values learning—rather than just time-building—will accelerate your progress and keep your experience enjoyable.

4. Fit, Availability, and Learning Environment

Flight training is deeply personal. You’ll be learning new skills, facing challenges, and spending many hours together. Your instructor should make you feel seen and supported—not rushed, judged, or left behind.

Consider:

• Do you feel safe and encouraged to make mistakes?
• Is your instructor patient and attentive?
• Do they take the time to explain decisions and outcomes clearly?

Also, ask about:

• Scheduling expectations: Can they fly when you’re available? Will you face long gaps between lessons?
• Backup plans: What happens if their aircraft is down? Do they have alternates?
• Flexibility: Will they work with your pace, or do they push everyone through the same track?

You deserve an instructor who treats your success as a shared responsibility, not just your own burden.

5. Teaching Tools and Resources

A structured training process often leads to better outcomes. Ask if your instructor uses:

• A published and structured syllabus (for both flight and ground instruction).
• Pre- and post-flight briefings to set expectations and reflect.
• Checklists and logs to avoid repetition and ensure progress.
• Digital tools like simulators, flight apps, or training trackers.
• Lesson previews: Your instructor tells you what new subjects or maneuvers will be introduced in the next lesson so you can read up on them beforehand.

Instructors who prioritize these elements are more likely to deliver consistent, high-quality education—even across multiple instructors if needed.

6. Realistic Expectations and Student Responsibility

Even with a great flight instructor, your progress also depends on your preparation, attitude, and mindset. Good learners:

• Show up on time, ready to fly.
• Take notes and review between lessons.
• Ask thoughtful questions and track their goals.
• Communicate openly about challenges or discomforts.
• Study in advance: Read up on the topics or maneuvers that will be introduced in the next lesson before arriving at the airport.

Flight training is a partnership. The right instructor will expect your best—but also inspire it.

7. Peer Feedback and Reviews

Don’t just rely on marketing. Ask current students what their training timeline has been like, what they like most about their instructor, and whether they’ve felt supported through tough moments.

And don’t forget: Flying with multiple instructors throughout your training can expose you to new styles, techniques, and safety perspectives. Even if you love your primary flight instructor, consider supplementing with another voice along the way.

8. Online & Hybrid Training Options

Virtual instruction has become a good complement to in-air lessons. More and more flight instructors now offer:

• Ground school via digital meeting platforms (e.g. Google Meet, Zoom).
• Shared document reviews, weather briefings, and checkride prep online.
• Screen-sharing to review sim flights or planning tools.

Simulator software like X-Plane or Microsoft Flight Simulator can help you practice procedures, radio work, or IFR concepts—even before getting into the cockpit. This hybrid model is especially helpful if you live far from an airport and/or need a more flexible schedule.

9. What the Experts Say

We asked a few seasoned flight instructors and aviation educators to share their top tips on what to look for in a great flight instructor. Here’s what they had to say:

Julie Boatman, CFI/CFII, ATP, and previous chief theoretical knowledge instructor
“Your relationship with your primary flight instructor is often one of the most important ones you make, both personally and in terms of your career if you choose a profession in aviation. Take the time to interview and spend a lesson with the instructor before committing to a program with them. A good match will propel you forward; a bad one can derail your training completely. A good instructor and/or a good flight school expects this interview process—and hesitation on either part is a big red flag.”

Steve Tupper, Aviation Lawyer, Airline Transport Pilot, Master CFI
"Personality plays a role in instruction. Both your personality and the personality of your instructor. You might be 16 years old and pretty laid-back and open to new experiences. Or you might be a 50-year-old dentist with a Type A personality and your eye on a V-tail Bonanza to get you to and from that vacation home. Available instructors might range from the 300-hour kid fresh from the Part 61 puppy mills of Florida or grizzled retired Naval Aviator for whom this is a retirement gig. Or anything in between. The FAA’s Fundamentals of Instruction book says that flight instructors should meet the student where the student is and tailor the instruction to the student as a learner. And instructors usually do a pretty good job of trying to do this. But the fact of the matter is that some people simply click better with some people. Pay attention to who you are and what your goals are for your flight training. And give some thought to whether a given instructor is likely to give you what you need."

John Niehaus, CFI, Co-host of The Calm Cockpit Podcast, Captain (Falcon & Gulfstream), Former Program Director at NAFI
"Flight instructors and students are a team—a crew—and both sides must make the effort to ensure your success. The single most important factor in choosing a flight instructor is finding someone who matches your learning and communication style. Students should never be afraid to properly interview a prospective instructor. Ask questions about how they communicate and teach—and even how they themselves learn, as that often reflects how they instruct. An instructor who doesn’t teach the way you learn isn’t necessarily a bad instructor—they just might not be the right fit for you."

Ryan Binns, CFI/CFII, Scenario-Based Educator, and Publisher of Free CFI Resources
"Finding a great instructor is one of the most challenging tasks for a student because unlike the rest of the aviation training journey, a student is usually on their own in this process. In many flight school environments, an instructor may even just be assigned blindly based on whoever is available. The right instructor can make all the difference between an enjoyable, efficient, and educational experience and a frustrating slog through your ratings. It is important for students to remember that they are in control of their own training journey and to insist on choosing the instructor that works for their personality, schedule, and aviation ambitions. A good instructor should begin any relationship with a discussion of your aviation (and life!) goals, and show a keen interest in your progress and success. Look for passion and enthusiasm about aviation and especially flight training. You are more likely to absorb and retain information when your instructor creates a positive and rewarding environment for flight training and takes an active interest in your progress."

Greg Brown, Aviation Author, Photographer, Podcaster, & Consultant
"For your first flight with a new instructor: Rather than a 20-minute “intro flight,” aka “discovery flight,” invest in a full first lesson (normally about an hour long). You’ll learn more and do more flying yourself, for a far better (and more motivational) introduction to piloting than on a shorter ride. Along with being knowledgable, your instructor should be patient, calm, and thorough, someone who listens well to you, and has a relaxed sense of humor."
*Read the full article, “Choosing a Good Flight Instructor” on Greg Brown’s blog.

Rod Machado, Flight Instructor/Author/Speaker
"Ask yourself if you'd like to spend 40-plus hours in the cockpit and under the supervision of this person while learning how to fly. Is this person the type of individual who seems like he will have confidence in you? If not, then find someone else. Remember, you're the consumer, so act like one. Also, keep in mind that a good CFI is worth his or her weight in airplane parts. Once you find one, treat him or her well. Pay him what he's worth, and sing his praises to everyone. Good CFIs seldom get the credit they deserve."
*Read a list of suggested questions to ask when choosing your instructor, featured in Rod Machado’s article.

Russell Still, Founder at Gold Seal, ATP, Eight-time Master CFI
"An independent CFI can be an excellent choice. These folks may be more concerned about their reputations as good teachers since much of their business comes from word-of-mouth. When you interview independent instructors, ask about the curriculum and particularly the syllabus. The best pilot in the world may be a lousy teacher, and a newly minted CFI might be a phenomenal one. It is very hard to tell based solely on an interview. To boost your odds of getting a really good instructor, ask those that you interview how many people they have soloed, how many they have taken all the way through to their checkrides, and how many of those passed on the first try."
*Check out Gold Seal's guide: Choosing Your Flight Instructor.

Tim Haller, 777 Captain at American Airlines, FAA Gold Seal CFI
"The student / instructor relationship, is just that … a relationship. Successful relationships are built on communication and trust. Effective communication will bring about trust. Initially, try on several instructors. Find one that you can comfortably and effectively communicate with. That instructor must be able to adjust their teaching style to you the applicant. Experience helps but may not be necessary. The enthusiastic and resourceful relatively inexperienced CFI may be a great fit. But you the applicant, will have to determine that. If the fit isn’t right, keep searching for an instructor that’s the best fit. It’s your money, the quality of training and your success depends on the best CFI for you. Make an informed choice."

Todd Davis, Co-founder of Skyfarer Academy, Airline pilot with years of experience in flight instruction
"Being a great flight instructor is more than just being a great aviator. A great flight instructor is a listener, observer, and teacher. One of the most challenging objectives for a flight instructor is instilling proper judgement in a student, also know as aeronautical decision making (ADM). This is much more difficult to teach than how to fly the plane. Teaching proper judgement takes patience, restraint, and praise. Allowing students to safely make mistakes, is the best way for them to learn. This skill comes with experience and certain character. Ego’s need to be left on the ground, and the CFI and student must work as a team for this difficult learning objective to be achieved. Ultimately finding the best instructor, is finding the best teacher who shows patience and professionalism."

10. Final Thoughts: Choose Deliberately, Fly Confidently

This journey is yours—and it should feel like one of the most rewarding investments you’ll ever make. Choose an instructor not just based on availability, but on alignment with your learning style, personality, and aviation goals.

When you find the right CFI, your training becomes more than a series of lessons—it becomes an experience that shapes how you think, fly, and grow as a pilot.

Fly with confidence, ask questions early, and don’t settle for “good enough.” You deserve an instructor who elevates both your skills and your passion.

Related Articles

• How to Choose the Independent Flight Instructor Website and Find an Independent CFI
• Secrets of a Successful CFI